Friday, 13 November 2026

Wild Horse Nine

This is a version of a review airing on ABC Victoria's Statewide Mornings program on November 12, 2026.

(MA15+) ★★★★★

Director: Martin McDonagh.

Cast: John Malkovich, Sam Rockwell, Steve Buscemi, Mariana di Girolamo, AilĂ­n Salas, Tom Waits, Parker Posey.

He suddenly realised he wasn't on Christmas Island.

I was about to write an introduction for this review when I thought I'd better reread some of my previous reviews for Martin McDonagh films. Good thing I did, because my intro for The Banshees Of Inisherin is exactly what I was going to write to kick off my review of Wild Horse Nine.

It goes thus:

Martin McDonagh is yet to make a bad film. His debut In Bruges is iconic, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri was the best film of 2018, and even his weakest film Seven Psychopaths is wildly entertaining.

It was true of The Banshees Of Inisherin and it's true of Wild Horse Nine. McDonagh is still yet to make a bad film.

Plainly, after 25+ years of reviewing I'm running out of ideas. Thankfully, McDonagh is not. His blend of dark humour, savage violence, and deep existential themes is mesmerising. Wild Horse Nine fits his modus operandi - it's ridiculously funny, shockingly dark, and it ruminates on some big ideas around redemption, evil, death, and why the hell America continues to meddle with the notion of "regime change" in other nations.

The two main characters are responsible for some of those international meddlings. Set in Chile in 1973 ahead of the coup that would install militant dictator Pinochet, Chris (Malkovich) and Lee (Rockwell) are CIA agents who have been helping unsettle the situation in the South American nation.

But Chris is unwell and forgetting things, making him a liability. He heads to Easter Island with Lee, for reasons that aren't initially clear.




The slow-burn story is intriguing. Not only is McDonagh deft with a joke or a swear, but he unfolds his narratives in small but gripping ways. Why are they on Easter Island? What have they been doing in Chile? What's going on with Chris' health? What's going on with Lee and his wife? All these questions are asked and they slowly unravel as the plot winds to its satisfying and unavoidable conclusion.

But it's the relationship between Malkovich's also-slowly-unravelling Chris and Rockwell's hapless bystander Lee that is the heart of this film. The sweary antagonism, the silent macho-male love and care between them, the bonding, the humour - it's all fascinating. It's tapping into a theme of The Banshees Of Inisherin - the inability of men to deal with their emotions and relationships in a healthy way. The meaning of life is also dealt with, though not to the depth of The Banshees Of Inisherin. 

None of this would work in lesser hands, but Malkovich and Rockwell are pitch perfect, balancing the explosive violence and odd tenderness. Every line of dialogue is masterfully written and masterfully delivered. Malkovich gives the impression he's rambling improv, and Rockwell is along for the ride, though you know that's not the case with a McDonagh script.

Buscemi is also great in a very comedic bit part, while the cameos of Posey and Waits add a splash of colour to the film. The only rational people in the film are two Chilean students played by di Girolamo and Salas, who are wonderful and add poignant layers to the story.

Wild Horse Nine is a far more eccentric film than The Banshees Of Inisherin or Three Billboards. It grasps its themes more lightly and it's filled with more non sequitur moments. But it's just as funny, just as meaningful, and just as memorable.

Wild Horse Nine is the funniest film of the year, and possibly the best.

Monday, 2 November 2026

Wildwood

This is a version of a review airing on ABC Victoria's Statewide Mornings program on October 29, 2026.

(M) ★★★★

Director: Travis Knight

Cast: (voices of) Peyton Elizabeth Lee, Jacob Tremblay, Carey Mulligan, Mahershala Ali, Awkwafina, Amandla Stenberg, Tom Waits, Charlie Day, Arthur Knight, Angela Bassett, Richard E. Grant, Jake Johnson, Maya Erskine, Tantoo Cardinal.

"Did you say more feathers?"

You'd have to be crazy (and patient) to make a stop-motion film, let alone one as epic as this. The time and dedication required is nothing short of incredible. It takes a special breed of human to work on a movie like this. Fortunately, Laika are those people, and they make incredible stop-motion movies.

Making one in this day and age is a wonderful act of defiance - one that deserves a standing ovation. People claim to be artists because they can type a prompt into a soulless, art-stealing AI program. Spare me. Wildwood is art. It is art in every sense of the word. Typing a prompt into AI and calling yourself an artist is akin to punching in a selection on a jukebox and calling yourself a musician.

That is not to say Wildwood is perfect. Wildwood is a slightly bloated fantasy epic that wanders off into the forest a couple of times but it always gets back on the right track when it needs to, making for a thoughtful and heartfelt story of loss and finding your place in the world.

It's the story of Prue, a young girl who must rescue her brother Mac after he is stolen by a murder of crows and whisked away to the Impassible Wilderness. Along with a nerdy neighbourhood kid named Curtis, Prue must journey into the woods, where she stumbles on a whole new world in the midst of a civil war.




My first and biggest gripe with this film is a single song selection. During Wildwood's earliest and most important moment - when Mac is stolen by the crows - there is some banal rock song that plays, turning what should be one of the movie's earliest key emotional moments into a rollicking almost-joyous chase. In the trailer, I had chills watching glimpses of this scene. In the final movie, I was taken out of the moment and annoyed. This is one of those decisions that you wonder how it survived the long  and arduous production period.

Leaving that gripe aside, Wildwood is an incredible film. The level of artistry and attention to detail is remarkable. A surprisingly brutal climactic battle is the most astounding piece of stop-motion I've ever seen, but the whole film is kinda like that. You forget you're watching stop-motion and sink into the story, and then every so often you recognise the supreme level of artistry involved in a single moment.

The story is great and epic but far from flawless, which may be a fault of Colin Meloy and Carson Ellis' book. A diversion into a building run by a bureaucracy feels totally unnecessary, to the point where we forget that it existed until some of the characters from there return for the post-script. Removing this sub-plot could have streamlined things, and kept the focus on the good-vs-evil machinations and Prue's plight - the two things that make the movie so rivetting. 

It's worth noting the M rating on this one. I would have happily taken my 10-year-old to this one, but more sensitive kids will have a tough time with it. Wildwood opens with a suicide and concludes with a brutal battle that's surprisingly bloodthirsty for a family film. In the '80s, this would've got a PG, right alongside those other great all-ages outings Gremlins and Indiana Jones & The Temple Of Doom. In this day and age, it's a well warranted M.

Laika makes incredible films and this is their most ambitious to date. And while effort alone doesn't warrant accolades, Wildwood deserves all of them. A marvellous story, with great characters in an epic landscape, Wildwood is up there with Kubo & The Two Strings and Coraline for Laika's best films.

Gremlins 2 is better than Gremlins

Gremlins (1984)

(PG) ★★★

Director: Joe Dante.

Cast: Zach Galligan, Phoebe Cates, Hoyt Axton, Polly Holliday, Frances Lee McCain, Judge Reinhold, Dick Miller, Glynn Turman, Keye Luke, Corey Feldman, Edward Andrews.


"And now... Tubular Bells."


The 1980s were a wild and scary place for an easily frightened movie-loving kid. Torment and terror lay around every corner. 

Horses died in swamps, overcome by sadness. That lovely guy who invented The Muppets made a puppet film that was pure nightmare fuel. A Wizard of Oz sequel turned out to be horrifying because heads could be removed and if you touched the sand you died. Even the ending of the greatest adventure of all time had faces melting. 

It’s only in this landscape that a movie like Gremlins could have been made. Part cornball cartoon, part check-under-the-bed horror, it tried to walk a line that only truly existed in the '80s - the hitherto unexplored zone between kids entertainment and bed-wetting terror. In fact, Gremlins and Indiana Jones & The Temple Of Doom led censors to rewrite the ratings system in the US, because the line those two films walked wandered straight into places too dark for most kids. After all, nothing says "kids movie" quite like stuffing a living creature in a blender or a microwave, or ripping out the still-beating heart of a terrified man.

Joe Dante, a director renowned for mixing "the 1950s-style B movie genre with 1960s radicalism and cartoon comedy" (according to Wikipedia), attempted to blend his trademark cartoon comedy stylings with some genuine scares in Gremlins. The opening of the film is bizarrely wacky, as one by one we're introduced to a number of characters who are part of an OTT comedy from the '60s or '70s. Hoyt Axton is a goofy inventor, Judge Reinhold is a deputy bank manager/chad, Polly Holliday is a wannabe-dog killing grinch landlord, and Dick Miller is a tractor-driving xenophobe. Each is perfectly in sync with the oddball tone of the weird jokes that sorta-kinda land in the opening half hour.

But then the tone changes. In the middle of this is the cute Mogwai named Gizmo and its ominous instructions, and the 1984 teen-ish power couple of Zach Galligan (Billy) and Phoebe Cates (Kate), who are playing it very straight (as is the indomitable Frances Lee McCain as Billy's mom). They are starring in an entirely different movie - a scary movie where they are oblivious to the goofiness around them. Their movie occupies the bulk of the film but it's jarring to see them interact with the other actors who have seemingly wandered in from a comedy shooting on the same lot (which just so happens to be the town square lot where Back To The Future was filmed).




It's this blend of styles that was the selling point of Gremlins in 1984 and its biggest downfall rewatching it 42 years later. The funny-but-scary mix never quite works outside of the Gremlins themselves, who, being chaos incarnate, can get away with doing outlandishly oddball things in the middle of their killing sprees. But even then, they are pushing it. Yes, it's funny to watch them take over a bar and play cards and swing on the ceiling fans and get drunk, but we still need to be terrified of these reptilian Lokis.  

The fact we are still scared of them is largely down to the character design, the incredible puppetwork, and the insanity they bring to Kingston Falls. We can tolerate their cartoonish natures (though the scene where they cut loose in a bar, funny as it is, really does push it), but the film stumbles between its two tones. 

When it works, it's great, but the first half an hour is clunky, Axton's narration is utterly redundant, a subplot about the aforementioned grinch landlord goes absolutely nowhere, and the film frequently tries to blend cartoonish sound effects with its scariest moments. Ultimately the scares are too scary and the laughs are too goofy for it to meet in the middle.

The film's unevenness extends to its moral. Dick Miller's character, who doesn't trust foreigners or foreign products is ultimately proven right in a way - the cause of the problems comes from a Chinatown shop dealing in artifacts from the Orient. It's a xenophobic vindication for the town racist. But the mystical Chinese shopkeeper swoops in at the end to reclaim the Mogwai and tell the stupid Americans they're too ignorant and destructive to have something so cool. So turns it out everyone hates people from other countries, I guess. And everyone's right - the foreign monster causes the problem, but only because the dumb Americans can't follow the rules.

Gremlins is a flawed classic. It's goofiness aside, it's got some good scares, the Gremlins themselves are incredibly disconcerting villains, and the finale, as zany as it is, is a thrilling climax. Its technical achievements are also out of this world. The robotics and pupperty is next level, and the final moments of a melting Stripe are truly remarkable.

But probably its biggest success is its high concept. Even if you haven't seen Gremlins, you know at least two of the key three rules (don't get 'em wet, don't feed 'em after midnight) and you know what happens if you break those two key rules - little monsters happen. It's a brilliant plot, and one that succeeds and thrives for 75 per cent of the film.

---------------------------------------------------

Gremlins 2: The New Batch

(PG) ★★★★

Director: Joe Dante.

Cast: Zach Galligan, Phoebe Cates, John Glover, 
Robert Prosky, Robert Picardo, Christopher Lee, Haviland Morris, Dick Miller.

"And I said, 'Joe, honey, I don't wanna be in your stinking sequel'."

All the things that are wrong with the first Gremlins film are right with the second one. And I realise how controversial it is to state such a thing.

It's still not perfect but The New Batch nails its tone right from the start. Yes, it's bonkers, but it's consistently bonkers, and Galligan and Cates fit in so much better. The scares are more kiddy friendly but also fit in with the comedy better. And the laughs are far funnier this time around. Right from the get-go, Gremlins 2 is aiming to be an oddball B movie, and it is.

And yes, we can do without the fourth wall-breaking scene that literally derails the film. It might've worked in the cinema, in the moment, but it was hokey then and it's hokey now. Some of the other meta-jokes fall flat, such as Leonard Maltin reviewing the first film. And you could rightly argue it's nowhere near as scary as the original.

But Gremlins 2 has so much going for it. It leans into its B movie ideas far more, complete with Christopher Lee as a mad scientist, its pop culture references are en pointe, and it has something bigger and better to say than the first film - that corporate American greed and inane tech-reliance will be our undoing. And here we are. 

One of the key sorta-villains is a parody of Donald Trump who proves to be an idiotic buffoon, completely disconnected from reality. John Glover makes the character Daniel Clamp way more sympathetic, but the idea cuts through.

In general, it's a send-up of sequels, of disposable pop culture, and of America in general. The majority of the plot takes place in one "smart" building that proves to be incredibly dumb - it's a nightmare to get into, inside is a nightmare, and then fixing any problems within it are nigh-on impossible. That's America.  





Yes, Gremlins 2 is only good because of the hard work of the original. The high concept of the first film sets up so much of the second, allowing it to work as well as it does. Some of the best jokes are actually riffing on the silliness of the first film, and poking fun at that. Does Joe Dante have contempt for the original, or is he just seeing an opportunity for laughs? Who knows, but for mine, it works. Plus the bulk of the effects are incredible, and once again build on the remarkable puppetry and robotics of the original.

But for evenness of tone, for better laughs, and for deeper themes, Gremlins 2: The New Batch is a better film than the original. Whereas Gremlins is a mismatched horror-comedy, Gremlins 2 is a wild, full tilt B movie. Your nostalgia will say otherwise, but in the harsh light of 40-ish years hindsight, the sequel is indeed the better film.