![]() |
| Artwork by The Imaginative Hobbyist |
Now that the DCEU is dead, we can properly appreciate what an abject failure it was, from start to finish.
It's incredible that it took four films for them to make a good movie. It's bizarre that two films have basically the same title. It's ridiculous that there's an entire film that was pretty much completed yet never released (RIP Batgirl). It's insane how many DCEU films were in various stages of production (Wikipedia lists 39 projects). It's patently dumb that Warner Bros released a non-DCEU Batman film and two Joker films at the same time it was trying to build a unified cinematic universe (although two-thirds of those non-DCEU films are outstanding).
The whole pursuit was an unfocused, unmitigated disaster. DC tried to copy Marvel's homework but changed it so much they threw out all the right answers. Of the 15 films (16 if you count the Snyder Cut), only six or maybe seven made their money back, and that might be a generous interpretation. And critically speaking, only eight films were rated "fresh" on Rotten Tomatoes, and one of those is the Snyder Cut.
Which brings me to the fact I'm not bothering to include Joss Whedon's Justice League in this list. Now the Snyder Cut is out there, there is no reason for the patently inferior Whedon Cut to exist, so let's pretend it doesn't and move on, shall we?
The DCEU is dead, long live the DCU.
1. The Suicide Squad
It's kinda hilarious that the best film and the worst film of the DCEU are basically the same film. James Gunn's crack at the Suicide Squad concept is so much fun, it's ridiculous. Ultra-violent, ultra-funny and ultra-unhinged, it works where the first version didn't because it has stakes, it has strong characters, it has style without forgoing substance, it's hilarious, and it has a bit of complexity to it. It makes the most of its idea and has a unique feel to it - something few other films in the DCEU accomplished.
2. Wonder Woman
After three misfires, the DCEU finally produced a good film. Wonder Woman worked because its themes and characters were so beautifully delivered and intertwined. The naive Diana and the war-weary Steve looked at the insanity of WWI through fresh eyes because of each other's presence, and this helped make this story something special. Gal Gadot is truly wonderful, has real chemistry with Chris Pine, and Patty Jenkins delivered not just a great superhero movie, but a great movie. The No Man's Land sequence remains one of the best of the DCEU.
3. Blue Beetle
Family. You can't have a Fast & Furious movie without it, and it's the secret sauce to this Latino-themed adventure. Funny, heartfelt and exhilarating, Blue Beetle deserved a better fate than to be a late franchise bomb. It's got more heart and guts than just about anything in the DCEU, and it's hard to see how the new DCU could reboot this and do a better job.
4. The Flash
A surprisingly well-plotted and fun dive into DC and its multiverses that bombed in no small part because of Ezra Miller's alleged criminal active and generally insane behaviour and also because some of its CGI looked crap. It's a shame, because separated from that, it's one of the best DCEU films, thanks in so small part to Miller's dual performances. Throw in the return of Michael Keaton's Batman, an interesting twist on the Superman story, some clever time travel shenanigans, and the best bunch of super-cameos outside Deadpool & Wolverine, and you've got an unexpected DCEU gem.
5. Shazam!
Origin tales are a dime a dozen, but none are as fun as Shazam's. Zachary Levi brings great joy to the role of a grown-ass superhero who is actually a 14-year-old kid, and the scenes where he tests his powers and uses his adult persona to buy beer are hilarious. While it descends into a typical rock-'em-sock-'em showdown against a so-so villain (played well by Mark Strong), it's sweet little foster family subplot gives the film an edge over most of the rest of the DCEU.
6. Zack Snyder's Justice League
Given time to breath and exist, Snyder's four-hour epic is actually a fine piece of superhero melodrama. Cyborg's origin story and character arc elevate the film, but everyone benefits from the expansive runtime, even Steppenwolf, who becomes infinitely more interesting. Snyder's vision is a half-hour prune away from being elite, but it manages to be a solid take on the Justice League and a surprisingly decent pay off on the unfortunately terrible films that preceded it.
7. Birds Of Prey (And The Fantabulous Emancipation Of One Harley Quinn)
The most stylish of the DCEU films, this is some seriously blood-splattered popcorn. It's not quite all style, no substance (although the ending absolutely is) - most of the film succeeds when Harley Quinn unleashes her emotional problems in wholly unhealthy ways. Margot Robbie shines, and the film juggles her various sidekicks and their back stories reasonably well. All in all, a fun mess.
8. Shazam! Fury Of The Gods
Better than many people would have you believe, Shazam 2 is packed with heart, humour and a half-decent plot about pissed-off gods trying to reclaim their powers from the brats that got said powers out of nowhere in the first film. Despite the horrible miscasting of Lucy Liu and Helen Mirren (Mirren at least gives it her all), the film gets a long way on the what-the-hell-are-we-doing charm of its heroes and the theme that makes every Fast & Furious film tick - family. The number of fun DCEU movies is quite small, but this is one of them.
9. Aquaman
While it succeeds in making its fish-controlling hero a badass (full points to Jason Momoa), Aquaman struggles to live up to its expectations. Painted into a corner by having already introduced the character in other films yet trying to tell his origin story here without actually telling his origin story, but also struggling under the weight of its mythology and its quest to find the right tone, it's as if this CG-drenched tsunami was dead in the water before it started. Yet it does a semi-splendid job at times, almost making this the one that got away, were it not for an often turgid script, and the non-existent chemistry of Nicole Kidman and Temuera Morrison.
10. Man Of Steel
Henry Cavill was a great Superman - it's a shame he never got a great movie to go with his chiseled jaw and impressive presence. Snyder's attempt to make an oh-so-serious Kal-El film leaves the audience strangely bored, as the film gets bogged down in repetition and absurd dialogue. It has its moments and Michael Shannon's Zod is great, but it doesn't thrill like it should (or like James Gunn's 2025 Superman did). Eventually its violence and dour tone becomes overwhelming, and not even Cavill's charm can save the day.
11. Black Adam
Better than expected, due to the fascinating ambiguity of its anti-hero, and a colourful array of side characters. But the latter are wasted and even Dwayne Johnson's star wattage can't overcome the fact this devolves into a boring punchathon where it never ever feels like Black Adam can be harmed, let alone killed. There is the kernel of a good movie in here somewhere, and that good movie would definitely have more of Pierce Brosnan's Dr Fate in it.
12. Wonder Woman 1984
Similarly to Black Adam, there is a great idea hiding in this mess of movie - what would happen if everyone in the world got what they wanted? Led by an enigmatic turn from Pedro Pascal as Maxwell Lord, Wonder Woman 1984 is so close to being a worthy follow-up except that its worldwide disaster emerges almost without explanation, its 1984 setting proves meaningless, and the return of Steve Trevor (Chris Pine) never feels right. Gal Gadot does her best, but the film even fumbles what Wonder Woman represents, reducing her to a lovelorn puppy still mourning someone who died 60 years earlier.
13. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
"Wait - your Mum's name is Martha too?". Leaving aside this fumbled attempt at finding a shared humanity between its titular heroes, BvS fails spectacularly and repeatedly with its scattershot plotting, misjudged characters, and by trying to force a narrative that never sticks, all the while winking maniacally at the audience. Jesse Eisenberg's portrayal of Lex Luthor is never scary and Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman feels wedged into the film out of contractual obligation. Things spark up in the third act, but it's a gruelling trek to get there, and by then you're wondering why they bothered.
14. Aquaman & The Lost Kingdom
If the DCEU wasn't dead already by the time this limp Aquaman sequel dived into the franchise, this would've been the film that killed it. Poorly plotted and terrible to look at, you actually feel for the actors as they go through their paces trying to save this damp mess. Jason Momoa and Patrick Wilson struggle to make the film's failed humour work, while Nicole Kidman again seems to have wandered in from different movie. Only Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and Randall Park acquit themselves well, and they struggle against the naff plot and dodgy dialogue. There are elements of the story that are cool, but the whole thing is a big dumb mess.
A chaotic mess of a shambles of a binfire of a film that takes forever to get going, then goes nowhere. The only saving graces are Robbie's Harley Quinn and a vaguely charismatic turn by Smith as Deadshot. All set-up, no plot. All style, no substance. All sizzle, no sausage. If not for Quinn, you wouldn't bother at all.





















